As The Insider reports, attorney Steven Ferrell said doctors still cannot confirm whether Pike will fully stabilize. She has been in the hospital under guard since the evening of September 30, and medical staff are trying to flush pentobarbital out of her system; two doses of it were administered to her during the procedure.
Ferrell said that, as far as he knows, Pike has not regained consciousness at all since the botched execution. According to him, the prognosis may remain unclear for several more days, and if the woman survives, her legal competence will be called into question.
Anesthesiologist and Emory University professor Joel Zivot, whom the defense brought in as an expert, believes Pike may have suffered irreversible brain damage due to complications during the procedure. He thinks the intravenous catheters may have malfunctioned, and the drug did not enter the bloodstream but instead went into the tissue around the veins; a court filing submitted by the lawyers says that after she was taken to the hospital, both of Pike’s arms were swollen, burned, and covered in blisters.
The execution attempt was made on the evening of September 30 at Riverbend Maximum Security Institution in Nashville. Staff tried several times to gain access to the woman’s veins, then administered two protocol-prescribed doses of pentobarbital, but she continued breathing and remained alive.
Immediately afterward, the Tennessee Department of Correction claimed that staff had carried out “every step” of the state-approved protocol and that the document did not provide for any further action after the second dose of the drug. Now an independent review must determine, among other things, whether the protocol was followed; Tennessee Governor Bill Lee has halted executions in the state and ordered an independent investigation.
This is already the second failed execution in Tennessee in 2026: in May, authorities were unable to execute Tony Carruthers when only one intravenous line could be established. After the failed attempt, the state’s corrections chief, Frank Strada, announced his resignation and will leave the post at the end of October.
Pike was supposed to become the first woman executed in Tennessee in more than 200 years; she was sentenced to death for the murder of 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer in 1995, when Pike herself was 18. She did not deny involvement in the murder, and her lawyers spent years seeking to overturn the sentence, citing, among other things, sexual abuse in childhood and mental disorders; after the botched execution, the defense asked the governor to commute the death sentence to life imprisonment.
Sources
